Week 74: What Guy Ate Last Week (part 1?)—Virgil’s Cafe
Author: admin // Category: Eating out, Food reviewA typically “spring” week in the Midwest—a few warm, almost-hot days, and even a touch of snow. It was Restaurant Week in Cincinnati… one of at least 3 big ones in the city I’m aware of. Normally, I’m all about getting out there and trying some new places with interesting and affordable fare. Unfortunately, it wasn’t to be this week, but I did have a lunch I’m eager to write about.
Jayson told me about Virgil’s in Bellevue, KY a few weeks ago. It sounded interesting enough, and I put it on my list of places to check out sometime soon. Well, as many of you know Guy Fieri was in town last week filming for his hit Food Network TV show, “Diners, Drive-In’s, and Dives.” I’ll be the first to admit that I really like that show. It’s hokey and silly, and I’m not really convinced that Guy has big-time food cred (and that TGI Friday’s announcement, let alone the game show hosting spot, might be putting a little dent in whatever credibility he has), but the show is entertaining and full of (mostly) places I find comfortable and fun.
Anyway, when he hit Cincinnati, he made it to three places: Blue Ash Chili, Terry’s Turf Club, and Virgil’s. So, a word of warning: go now. When the show airs, you can expect more waits than usual at these spots, especially Terry’s which I hear he really loved!
Anyway, this week I had a free lunch and Jayson and I decided to head to Virgil’s. I will say that this was not what I had expected from a Guy Fieri-featured place. It had a refined, almost gentrified air about it. It was relatively quiet and filled with lots of “old ladies lunching.” The menu wasn’t dramatic, adventurous, or diner/drive-in/divey, but the food looked really good!
In any case, I started with a cup of bison chili. Having recently made some bison chili myself, I learned first-hand how hard it is to coax great flavor out of such a delicate meat. Well, I can tell you, this is one of the best cups of chili I have had in a very long time. The consistency was neither thick nor runny—just the right amount of “give.” The flavor wasn’t defined by the add-ons or unnecessary stocks—it tasted like tomatoes, chilies, and… bison. So, so good. Tasty without being rich, boldly flavorful without being too hot, this could have been dinner just as it is.
I asked the server what was “the dish to get” and without hesitation she told me about the pastrami. This is what I figured as it seems that that’s the only dish I’ve ever read about at the place. In any case, with the hearty recommendation in hand, I plunged in. And folks, this was good. They hand-season their meat, and it showed. Though it was served reuben-style, the flavor was all pastrami. Like the best of its type, this sandwich was deeply spiced to balance the flavor of the very tender meat. Good sturdy toasted bread held its own and the sauerkraut and swiss did their job to provide the right accents. The sweet fries were pretty unremarkable, but with a sandwich this good it doesn’t matter.
So I’m not sure what Guy’s “angle” on this place will be—it’s not kitchy or crazy. But the sandwich is so good, it makes me hope that maybe the food will rule the day!
I’m debating if I’m going to do the "Guy Tour” and hit up Blue Ash Chili and Terry’s in the next couple of weeks. I wouldn’t do it for any form of Guy idolatry, but just because these are great places every Cincinnatian should know before the world does! Stay tuned!






