Week 92: Wishful thinking at Maribelle’s (plus a SA highlight)
Author: admin // Category: Eating out, Food reviewMost days, I’m a pretty logical person, willing and able to take advice from friends and use it to make decisions. But sometimes, wishing and hoping inadvertantly becomes the order of the day—such is the occasion that brought me to Maribelle’s.
I drive Maribelle’s several times a week. It sits in an interesting little corner of the East End on Riverside Drive, surrounded by old homes and warehouses, with a view of the river from their lovely little patio. It just looks the part of an excellent local spot. And the menu… well, it’s interesting, fresh, and appetizing, with a good number of comfortable-without-being-dull kinds of choices. All in all, it looks like a gem of a find, and for me a convenient one, too.
What a shame I didn’t listen to my friend Liz.
I saw Liz the other week and the subject of restaurants comes up, as it often does, and somewhere along the way, Maribelle’s was mentioned. Liz was unequivocal: “It used to be great, but it isn’t anymore.” I asked why, and she simply said the food wasn’t up to par, despite the fact that she loved the place. Well, with such great weather yesterday, S & I were thinking about where we could go with a patio. The usual suspects came up, and after a bit of thinking I decided to mention Maribelle’s. We decided to go—how could we not, with the location, cuteness and menu?
We arrived at a lovely little table on the patio with a river view and had a fair time staring out at our fine river. A bit too much time—after about 5 minutes, the hostess returned and asked if we had been seen. We said we hadn’t and she asked our waiter to come see us, which he did. We immediately put in for beers (a small but serviceable selection on draft) and a flatbread appetizer. About five minutes later, the waters came. Several minutes later, the beers. And then we didn’t see anyone again until someone else brought our flatbreads, menus still on the table, entrees unordered. I recognize that I have a “thing” about timing, but I firmly believe that meal pacing may be the most important part of the interaction between server and kitchen and we were pretty severely let down on this evening.
The flatbread was a four-cheese balsamic flatbread. It was fine, but somehow added up to less than the sum of its parts. Soggy crust, heavy amounts of cheese, it was a bit heavy and uninteresting but we were happy just to have something to eat!
Eventually our server returned to take our orders—we both ordered seafood. (I had the barramundi and S had the wahoo special.) And we ordered a spinach salad to split as it looked good.
About five minutes later (!) the entrees arrived, with no sign of the salad. Our server graciously noted it would be removed from the bill and we tucked into our meal.
Sadly, I didn’t care for either dish. The barramundi was slightly (though not critically) overcooked, making it dry, and the look of the flake itself made me wonder if it was really fresh—it was dark and mottled in spots. The spicy romesco-style sauce on top was zesty and fun but it topped a fish I couldn’t really get behind. The radicchio that came under the fish was a nice textural balance but didn’t provide much flavor. We ordered potatoes gratin on the side—a dish that I think isn’t being served enough these days—it should be simple and delicious! These potatoes were advertised as potatoes gratin with lavender, interesting I thought. But lavender is almost all I could taste—it was very heavy-handed, and salt/pepper helped a little bit not enough. I finished them but only because of my love of potatoes. S’s wahoo was a little better, as the fish looked bright and fresh, though I still found it a little tasteless.
Interestingly, as we were eating our entrees, the salad eventually did arrive… and it was the best thing of the meal. Fresh spinach, pieces of mandarin orange and red onion, very nice and vibrant. Too bad it was dessert!
So, Liz, you were right. Damn. I will consider going back but will stick to beer and basics on that patio on a lovely night. Maribelle’s has so much going for it, they just need to spend a little more time on those key elements of food freshness/quality and service/timing. I’m going to keep pulling for this place!
A Note from South Africa: Our Durban Indian Experience
While in South Africa, we had a night in the city of Durban, of note to soccer fans as the home of that awesome looking stadium with the “picnic basket handle” top. Well, it’s the country’s (and in fact continent’s) best home for Indian food. We ventured out to a place called Palki in a quiet residential neighborhood. It was oddly quiet on a Friday night and the owners were in the next room watching “Conan the Barbarian” on TV. That’s an image. But we ate very well—S had butter chicken, but not the kind of butter chicken I’m used to. Clearly cooked in butter but this was a darker, richer (and a little oilier) sauce. Lovely. I had a madras curry chicken which was deep, rich, and tasty. Compared to “Cincinnati Indian,” I’d say this food was a little oilier, but bursting with flavor, color, and texture. Really nice. Though I can confirm that I just don’t like pappardums. Anywhere. More next week!















